The Bharat NCAP (New Car Assessment Program) recently conducted crash tests on several new vehicles, including the Tata Curvv and Citroen Basalt SUV coupes. The results revealed that the Curvv achieved an impressive 5-star rating, consistent with Tata's reputation for safety, while the Basalt secured a commendable 4-star safety rating, indicating Citroen's commitment to enhancing vehicle safety. In this article, we will compare the crash test results of the Curvv and Basalt SUV coupes, highlighting their performance and safety features.
Results Comparison
| Parameters | Tata Curvv | Citroen Basalt |
|---|---|---|
| Adult Occupant Protection (AOP) Score | 29.50/32 | 26.19/32 |
| Child Occupant Protection (COP) Score | 43.66/49 | 35.90/49 |
| Adult Safety Rating | 5-star | 4-star |
| Child Safety Rating | 5-star | 4-star |
| Frontal Offset Deformable Barrier Test Score | 14.65/16 | 10.19/16 |
| Side Movable Deformable Barrier Test Score | 14.85/16 | 16/16 |
| Dynamic Score (Child Safety) | 22.66/24 | 19.90/24 |
Tata Curvv Performance
In the frontal offset deformable crash test, the Tata Curvv demonstrated good protection for the driver’s and passenger’s head, neck, and chest. However, the driver's left leg received a marginal rating. In the side movable barrier test, the protection for the driver’s head and abdomen was rated as good, while the chest received an adequate rating. The side pole test further showed that the driver’s head, chest, abdomen, and pelvis received good protection.
For child safety, the dynamic score for the 18-month-old in front and side protection was 7.07 out of 8 and 4 out of 4, respectively. The 3-year-old child scored similarly well with 7.59 out of 8 in frontal protection and a perfect score of 4 out of 4 for side protection.
Citroen Basalt Performance
In the frontal offset deformable barrier test, the Citroen Basalt provided good protection for the driver’s and co-driver's head and neck. However, the driver’s chest received marginal protection, and the co-driver’s chest was rated as adequate. Both drivers’ thighs received marginal protection, while the driver’s left leg and right leg received marginal and adequate protection, respectively. The co-driver's left leg received adequate protection, while the right leg received good protection.
The Basalt excelled in the side impact test, achieving a full score of 16 out of 16 due to good protection for the head, chest, abdomen, and pelvis. The side pole test also showed good protection across all evaluated areas.
For child safety, the 18-month-old received a perfect score of 8 out of 8 for front protection and 4 out of 4 for side protection. However, the 3-year-old child had a disappointing score of 3.9 out of 8 for frontal impact protection, despite scoring 4 out of 4 for side impact.
Key Takeaways
The Citroen Basalt lost points in the frontal offset deformable barrier test due to marginal protection for the driver’s chest and adequate protection for the co-driver’s chest. In contrast, the Tata Curvv provided good protection for both driver's and the co-driver’s chests, resulting in a higher overall score.
Safety Features Comparison
Tata Curvv:
6 airbags (standard)
Electronic stability control (ESC)
Electronic parking brake with auto-hold
ABS with EBD
Front and rear parking sensors
360-degree camera with blind view monitoring
Tyre pressure monitoring system (TPMS)
Level 2 advanced driver assistance systems (ADAS) including adaptive cruise control, lane keep assist, and automatic emergency braking.
Citroen Basalt:
6 airbags (standard)
ESC
ABS with EBD
Hill-start assist
TPMS
Rear parking camera (lacks front parking sensors and a 360-degree camera)
Price Range & Rivals
Tata Curvv: Rs 10 lakh to Rs 19 lakh
Citroen Basalt: Rs 7.99 lakh to Rs 13.83 lakh
Both the Tata Curvv and Citroen Basalt can also be regarded as alternatives to compact SUVs like the Hyundai Creta, Maruti Grand Vitara, Volkswagen Taigun, Honda Elevate, and MG Astor.
In conclusion, both SUV coupes showcase impressive safety features and ratings, with the Tata Curvv slightly edging out the Citroen Basalt in terms of overall safety performance.