Test Drive Day Out: Evaluating 8 Cars and a Surprising Winner
After deciding to replace the beloved Datsun Redigo AMT with over 70,000 km on the odometer, the search for a new city car began. The family set a budget of ₹12 lakh on-road and shortlisted several contenders: Hyundai Nios and Exter, Nexa’s Ignis, Fronx 1.2, and Baleno, Maruti Swift, Tata Punch, and Honda Amaze. Here’s a detailed account of the test drives and why the Maruti Swift was chosen.
Dealership: Modi Hyundai, Thane
Experience: Despite high expectations, the Nios Sportz AMT was underwhelming. The steering feedback was disappointing, even compared to the old Datsun Redigo. The Exter, unfortunately, mirrored the same issues, along with unresponsive throttle inputs.
Dealership: Tata Motors
Experience: The Punch impressed with its build quality and ride comfort. However, the engine’s lackluster performance and jerky AMT gearbox were deal-breakers, particularly at the ₹11 lakh price point.
Dealership: Nexa
Experience: The Ignis stood out with its tall-boy design, responsive engine, and better-than-expected steering feedback. Its energetic drive and practical features made a strong case, though its aging design and aesthetics were points of concern.
Dealership: Nexa
Experience: Both the Fronx and Baleno were solid contenders but did not surpass the Ignis in driving enjoyment and overall value.
Dealership: Honda
Experience: The Amaze’s CVT offered a smooth ride, but the car felt outdated. Lack of certain features and the anticipation of a new generation model were deterrents.
Dealership: Maruti Arena
Experience: The Swift exceeded expectations. Comfortable seats, well-thought-out ergonomics, and quality improvements over previous models were evident. The AMT performed smoothly with minimal jerks, and the steering provided good feedback at city speeds and higher. The Swift delivered a fun driving experience, crucial for city commutes, making it the ultimate choice despite initial reluctance due to its three-cylinder engine and reduced power.
The Maruti Swift emerged as the clear winner after comprehensively evaluating all shortlisted cars. It offered a blend of comfort, performance, and practicality that was unmatched by its competitors, making it the ideal replacement for the family’s city car.
Also Read: